Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Park51 Community Center

I've been following the Park51 Community Center (formerly known as Cordoba House) issue and it's apparent that the folks involved with this project will be able to move forward in the near future. This a good thing in the sense that it shows that the powers that be in NYC are not swayed by irrational Islamophobia. However, I wonder why this center will be housed so close to Ground Zero. There's a lot of raw emotion connected to Ground Zero given what happened on 9/11 and as a result, it's completely understandable that many non-Muslims would be upset by the prospect of having a mosque (or whatever it is that it's being called) so close to the site of the former World Trade Center. I wonder what was the intent of the folks behind this project in selecting the site that they've selected. I'm not trying to read too much into anything nor am I trying to insinuate anything negative - I just wonder why this place had to be constructed at this specific location. Yes, I know that many Muslims died as victims on 9/11 but I also know that this area is very sensitive to Americans and as such, I believe that provocative actions (whether intentional or not) can be counter-productive to improving the image of Islam/Muslims among non-Muslims in the West.

With that said, I also wonder how far away folks would like the Park51 center to be built. Is New Jersey too close? How about California or Hawaii? My suspicion is that no matter how far we go from Ground Zero, nowhere is far enough for some people.

In addition to this, some people have commented on a New York Times article on this same issue that they'd welcome this center in the area when Saudi Arabia allows synagogues and churches to be built there. In my mind, this is a stupid straw man argument. Saudi Arabia and the United States are two completely different countries. Saudi Arabia is an avowedly Muslim and Islamic country and as a result, allowing construction of non-Muslim houses of worship wouldn't make any sense. On the other hand, the United States is a (supposedly) secular nation founded upon (among other things) freedom of religion. Banning the building of mosques in the US is profoundly un-American and violates the spirit (if not the letter) of the First Amendment, in my opinion.

No comments: