Sunday, May 30, 2010

Applying Modern Norms to the Past

I was just reading through some of the comments on a piece that Haroon Moghul wrote for the Huffington Post entitled "What Does China Have to Do with Islam and Democracy?" One of the things that struck me (and this is something that I've thought about before) is how many of us tend to apply the norms and ideals of today to the past. I believe that this is a mistake because applying constantly changing principles to an unchangeable past is a recipe for disaster. What may have been perfectly acceptable in the past is now verboten by today's standards (note that I'm not saying that today's standards are always right). For example, in the past, monarchy was an accepted form of government. However, today, monarchies are generally frowned upon as the modern emphasis is on secular democracy as the ideal system of government (I don't agree - I firmly believe that ruling by Allaah's decree is the only path to salvation and success). If we look at monarchies of the past with a 21st-century mindset, we'd naturally wonder what was wrong with the people under the rule of the kings or queens and why they didn't revolt against the rulers and try to implement a democratic system. This, in my opinion, would be a big mistake as the systems of governance in place in the past may have been perfectly acceptable for the times and places where they were implemented.

Monday, May 24, 2010

Backwardness

It's been a long time since I've posted here (having nearly-3 month old twins will do that to you). I came across a recent blog entry on Muslimmatters.org (http://muslimmatters.org/2010/05/23/ever-wonder-whether-your-watch-is-too-fancy-to-wear-with-ihram-sunday-open-thread/) talking about a new tower that will soon be open in Makkah. The blog post is fine - it's the tone of some of the comments that I have an issue with. Apparently, it seems that many Muslims want the Ummah (particularly Makkah and Madinah) to be stuck in some sort of Middle Age-type time warp. These people have this notion of Makkah and Madinah being these simplistic, unsophisticated places where the Hujjaaj (those who make Hajj) or those who make 'Umrah can go back in time to a simpler, more antiquated environ. Apparently, the Saudi government shouldn't be making any attempt to modernize these places (e.g., expansion of Masjid al-Haram or constructing new hotels to accommodate the visitors to these holy cities), according to this view.

I wholeheartedly disagree with this idea. Times change, and people and places should evolve. Now, am I saying that Makkah and Madinah should turn into uber-metropolises that take on the characteristics of cosmopolitan locales? No, absolutely not. I do agree that these are holy places and should be treated as such. However, I also recognize that the Saudi government, by being entrusted with these sites, has a responsibility to make sure that they are taken care of and that there are adequate accommodations for the Hujaaj and those making 'Umrah. I can only imagine what these same folks might say if the Saudi government had decided to leave things as they were 30 years ago. The Haram would be much smaller than it is now and there would be a lot of chaos and confusion as people try to navigate their way around the two holy mosques. Indeed, the Saudi government has faced criticism before - one notable instance was in the aftermath of a stampede during Hajj in 2006 when more than 300 pilgrims died during a stampede. I can only imagine what the criticism would be if the Saudi government decided to accede to the viewpoint I've described and not done anything to enhance the Hajj experience (both in terms of making things flow easier and with more safety).